Toronto, the vibrant heart of Canada, is not just known for its iconic CN Tower or the bustling streets of Queen West. It’s also a culinary paradise, boasting flavors from around the globe. Among the myriad of delicacies the city has embraced, the deep dish pizza has carved out a special place, bringing a slice of Chicago right to our northern doorstep. As the layers of molten cheese, robust tomato sauce, and a perfectly crispy crust come together, it’s hard not to fall in love at first bite. If you’ve been on a quest for the most scrumptious deep dish pizzas in Toronto or simply curious about what the hype is all about, this guide is your golden ticket. Toronto’s pizza scene is as varied as its neighborhoods: from the sumptuous deep dish pizzas in the heart of the city to the top styles and unique pizzerias in Etobicoke and top pizzas in Scarborough. Dive in, and let’s embark on a cheesy journey through Toronto’s best deep dish offerings!
Here are the 14 places that serve the best deep dish pizza in Toronto:
- Descendant Detroit Style Pizza
- Pizzeria Via Mercanti
- Blondies Pizza
- North of Brooklyn Pizzeria
- Maker Pizza
- Pizza Libretto
- Cibo Wine Bar
- Terroni
- General Assembly Pizza
- Buddy’s Pizza
- Gusto 101
- Superpoint
- Mattachioni
- Pizza Thick
Descendant Detroit Style Pizza
While not Chicago-style deep dish, Descendant Detroit Style Pizza offers a pizza experience that’s thick and indulgent in its own right. Detroit-style pizza is characterized by a crispy, thick crust, often likened to a “deep-dish focaccia.” At Descendant, this crust becomes a canvas for an array of inventive toppings. One of their most beloved offerings is the “Jaffna” – a spicy and flavorful combination of kothu roti, mango chutney, cilantro cream, green onion, Calabrian chilis, and curry leaves. Every pizza at Descendant tells a story, reflecting the creativity and passion poured into each dish. The square slices, caramelized cheese edges, and an upside-down layering of ingredients make Descendant’s pizzas distinct and sought-after in Toronto’s culinary scene.
Address: 1168 Queen St E, Toronto, ON M4M 1L4, Canada
Pizzeria Via Mercanti
Pizzeria Via Mercanti, while not strictly a deep-dish pizzeria, has garnered accolades for its mouthwatering pizzas that echo the heart and soul of Italian traditions. Located in Toronto’s Kensington Market and other locations, this eatery’s atmosphere is as warm and inviting as the pizzas they serve. A must-try is their Margherita Pizza, which has received rave reviews for its authenticity and flavor. However, for those wanting a more deep-dish experience, their “Ripieno” – a stuffed pizza – is a hefty, delectable choice packed with cheese and toppings, encased in a golden crust. Pizzeria Via Mercanti stands out not just for its food, but also for its ambiance, which many describe as a genuine slice of Italy right in Toronto.
Address: 188 Augusta Ave, Toronto, ON M5T 2L4, Canada
Blondies Pizza
Blondies Pizza, with its bright and inviting aesthetic, beckons pizza lovers across Toronto. While not strictly a deep-dish joint, Blondies does offer a crust that’s heartier than your average thin slice. The establishment is renowned for its use of fresh, local ingredients, which shine brightly in every bite. Their pizzas, topped generously, present a mosaic of colors and flavors. The fan-favorite “Hawaii Five-O,” a delightful twist on the classic Hawaiian, boasts of roasted pineapple, bacon, and pickled jalapeños, promising a tantalizing combination of sweet, salty, and spicy. Another distinctive feature at Blondies is their vegan pizza options, ensuring that those with dietary restrictions don’t miss out on the fun. Their pizzas are as vibrant and dynamic as the city of Toronto itself, making Blondies a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.
Address: 1555 Dundas St E, Toronto, ON M4L 1K9, Canada
North of Brooklyn Pizzeria
A staple in Toronto’s pizza community, North of Brooklyn Pizzeria has been delivering slices that seamlessly blend traditional techniques with contemporary flavors. Their crust strikes a delightful balance between thin and thick, offering a hearty bite without being overwhelmingly dense. A crowd-pleaser is the “Killer Bee,” drizzled with honey to juxtapose its spicy Calabrese salami. This pizzeria’s commitment to sourcing high-quality ingredients is evident, resulting in slices that are both flavorful and fresh. Their unique collaborations, like the occasional specialty pie made in tandem with local chefs or brands, keep the menu exciting for regulars. With several locations scattered across the city, North of Brooklyn ensures that wherever you are, a stellar slice isn’t too far away.
Address: 650 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1E4, Canada
Maker Pizza
Maker Pizza is a name that resonates with Torontonians when they think of a gourmet pizza experience. Led by a team passionate about the art of pizza-making, Maker Pizza’s offerings stand out both in terms of flavor profiles and presentation. While they offer a variety of crust options, their thicker crusts certainly satiate those in search of a deeper, doughier bite. The “Frank’s Best” is a testament to their creativity, featuring caramelized onions, goat cheese, and rosemary atop a rich base of mozzarella and olive oil. Their pizzas are more than just a meal; they’re a culinary experience. What’s also commendable is their dedication to community, often participating in charitable events or collaborations, which further cements Maker Pizza’s position as a beloved establishment in Toronto’s food scene.
Address: 59 Cameron St, Toronto, ON M5T 2H1, Canada
Pizza Libretto
Nestled in multiple locations throughout Toronto, Pizza Libretto is a name synonymous with Neapolitan pizza. While not a traditional deep dish, their pizzas are characterized by a soft, chewy crust that’s slightly charred from wood-fired ovens, in accordance with true Neapolitan tradition. Pizza Libretto prides itself on authenticity, with their dough undergoing a minimum of 24-hour fermentation. One of their iconic pizzas is the “Margherita D.O.P.,” crafted with tomato, mozzarella, basil, and grated Grana Padano. The eatery also offers gluten-free crust options, ensuring that everyone can indulge. The ambiance of Pizza Libretto, often abuzz with chatter and the comforting aroma of baking pizzas, creates a perfect setting for a cozy evening in the city.
Address: 155 University Ave, Toronto, ON M5H 3B7, Canada
Cibo Wine Bar
Cibo Wine Bar offers an authentic yet modern take on Italian cuisine in Toronto. Their pizzas, while not the Chicago-style deep dish, boast a crust that’s both crispy and fluffy, a testament to the meticulous crafting process. A highlight of their menu is the “Diavola” pizza, with spicy Italian salami and chili peppers providing a kick of heat, beautifully balanced by the creaminess of the mozzarella. Apart from their delightful pizzas, what sets Cibo apart is their impressive wine selection, with an array of Italian wines that pair splendidly with the pizzas. The rustic and chic ambiance, coupled with an open kitchen concept, allows diners to witness the magic of pizza-making unfold before them, making the dining experience truly immersive.
Address: 522 King St W, Toronto, ON M5V 1L7, Canada
Terroni
Terroni, with its roots tracing back to 1992, has been an enduring staple in Toronto’s Italian culinary scene. Offering Southern Italian dishes, Terroni’s pizzas stand out for their thin crust, which is crispy at the base and slightly puffy around the edges. Their “Puzza” pizza, adorned with spicy salami, gorgonzola cheese, and fresh mozzarella, promises an explosion of flavors with every bite. Beyond just the food, Terroni provides an experience – with interiors that transport diners to Italy and a curated list of Italian wines. They also adhere strictly to traditional recipes, so much so that they don’t offer customizations on their pizzas, ensuring that patrons enjoy the dish as it’s meant to be. For those seeking an authentic Italian pizza experience in Toronto, Terroni is an unmissable spot.
Address: 57 Adelaide St E, Toronto, ON M5C 1K6, Canada
General Assembly Pizza
Located in the lively heart of Toronto, General Assembly Pizza is more than just a pizzeria; it’s an experience. Known for their artisanal pizzas that showcase a beautiful amalgamation of tradition and innovation, each pizza here is a masterpiece. Their crust is not the typical deep-dish style but carries a certain depth that provides a hearty bite. The “Loved Supreme” is a crowd favorite, featuring soppressata, kalamata olives, and a delightful mozzarella that melts into perfection. Unique to General Assembly is their Pizza Subscription service, which delivers artisanal frozen pizzas right to your doorstep. This innovative approach, combined with their commitment to quality, sets them apart in Toronto’s pizza scene.
Address: 333 Adelaide St W, Toronto, ON M5V 1R5, Canada
Buddy’s Pizza
Buddy’s Pizza, inspired by the deep-dish tradition, brings a chunk of the pizza haven right to Toronto. Their crust, thick and doughy, acts as a vessel carrying layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings, offering a rich bite every time. While many of their pies are noteworthy, their “Classic Cheese” is a testament to the saying “simplicity is the ultimate sophistication,” where the interplay of mozzarella, sauce, and crust shines brilliantly. The ambiance at Buddy’s is as comforting as their pizzas, with a laid-back vibe that’s perfect for a casual dine-in experience. If you’re seeking a taste reminiscent of the classic deep-dish joints, Buddy’s Pizza might just be your next stop.
Address: 3700 Midland Avenue, Toronto, Ontario M1V 0B3
Gusto 101
Gusto 101 is not just a pizzeria but a celebration of Italian cuisine in its entirety. Situated in a revamped industrial space, the ambiance offers a blend of rustic charm with modern elegance. Their pizzas, while not deep dish, are celebrated for the perfect crust, which strikes a balance between chewy and crispy. A popular choice is their “Mushroom,” boasting roasted wild mushrooms, truffle cream, and mozzarella that dances beautifully with the earthy flavors. Another unique aspect of Gusto 101 is their terrace, which, when weather permits, offers a delightful al fresco dining experience. With a curated wine list and an ambiance that oozes warmth, Gusto 101 promises more than just a meal—it’s an Italian soiree.
Address: 101 Portland St, Toronto, ON M5V 2N3, Canada
Superpoint
Superpoint, located in the Ossington area of Toronto, is a chic pizzeria and pasta bar known for its unique take on traditional dishes. While not a strict adherent to the deep-dish style, Superpoint’s pizzas have gained acclaim for their perfectly crispy yet chewy crust. Their signature “Superpoint” pizza is a delightful concoction of tomato, mozzarella, pepperoni, green olives, and fresh oregano, making it a sought-after choice among regulars. The ambiance exudes a cool, relaxed vibe, with a touch of rustic charm, making it perfect for both casual dinners and special occasions. An added draw is their wine list, curated to complement their menu, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Address: 184 Ossington Ave, Toronto, ON M6J 2Z7, Canada
Mattachioni
Mattachioni, tucked away in Toronto’s Junction Triangle, is a gem for those seeking authentic Italian flavors. Their pizzas, with a slightly thicker crust, are reminiscent of Roman-style pies. The hand-stretched dough is topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients, making each pizza a celebration of flavors. The “Tartufo” pizza, with its mozzarella, mushrooms, and truffle oil, is a favorite and showcases the eatery’s commitment to creating gourmet pies. Apart from their pizzas, Mattachioni is also known for its artisanal bread, which further speaks to their mastery over dough. With a cozy interior and a warm, welcoming vibe, dining at Mattachioni feels like a delightful Italian getaway.
Address: 1617 Dupont St, Toronto, ON M6P 3S8, Canada
Pizza Thick
As the name suggests, Pizza Thick stands out for its dedication to the deep-dish style. Each pie is a hearty, indulgent affair, with layers of cheese, toppings, and their signature sauce enveloped in a thick, buttery crust. Their “Classic Chicago” pizza, layered with pepperoni, green peppers, onions, and mushrooms, is a nod to the traditional deep-dish roots and is a crowd-pleaser. What sets Pizza Thick apart is not just their impeccable pizzas but also their dedication to maintaining authenticity. Patrons also rave about their friendly staff and the relaxed atmosphere, making it a perfect spot to enjoy a slice or two (or more) of deep-dish goodness.
Address: 1026 Queen Street E Toronto, ON M4M 1K4. Leslieville.
Pairing Recommendations
When indulging in a hearty slice of deep-dish pizza, the experience can be significantly elevated by pairing it with the right drink and side dishes. Here are our recommendations to complement the rich flavors of your deep-dish delight:
Best Drinks to Accompany Your Deep Dish Pizza:
Craft Beers: Particularly, ales and lagers. Their carbonation can help cut through the richness of the cheese and toppings, making each bite as delightful as the first. IPAs, with their hoppy bitterness, contrast beautifully with the sweetness of a tomato sauce.
Red Wine: Opt for wines with a robust character like Cabernet Sauvignon or Chianti. Their fruity undertones and tannic nature complement the savory toppings of the pizza. From the hearty depths of deep dish pizzas to the refined elegance of a wine glass, Toronto offers a seamless transition to its premier wine bars.
Soft Drinks: A classic cola or root beer has the right balance of sweetness and acidity to cleanse the palate between bites.
Iced Tea: The slight bitterness and refreshing nature of iced tea can be a perfect non-alcoholic pairing, especially when lightly sweetened.
Side Dishes That Complement Deep Flavors:
Caesar Salad: The crispness of romaine lettuce, combined with creamy Caesar dressing, offers a refreshing counterbalance to the deep flavors of the pizza.
Garlic Bread: While it’s a carb-on-carb choice, the aromatic flavor of garlic bread acts as a wonderful accompaniment, especially when dipped into marinara sauce.
Antipasti: A platter featuring olives, marinated vegetables, and cured meats introduces varied textures and flavors that juxtapose the density of a deep-dish pizza.
Roasted Vegetables: Lightly seasoned and roasted vegetables like bell peppers, zucchini, or eggplants add a healthy, flavorful side option to your pizza meal.
For those who love the indulgence of Toronto’s deep dish pizza but also seek halal options, the city offers a variety of halal pizza places.
Key Takeaways
- The city boasts a rich variety of pizzerias, each offering its unique take on deep-dish pizzas, from classic Chicago styles to Roman-inspired thick crusts.
- Notable establishments like Double D’s, Descendant Detroit Style Pizza, Pizzeria Via Mercanti, and others offer authentic and gourmet pizza experiences.
- Each pizzeria stands out for its specialties, whether it’s Pizza Libretto’s Neapolitan style, Mattachioni’s artisanal bread, or Superpoint’s blend of tradition and innovation.
- The right drink, be it craft beer, red wine, or a soft drink, can significantly elevate the pizza indulgence.
- Side dishes, from Caesar salads and garlic bread to antipasti and roasted vegetables, add layers of flavor and texture to the pizza meal.
- Toronto’s pizza landscape is dynamic, with establishments often introducing new flavors or collaborating with local brands. Regular visits or staying updated with these pizzerias can lead to delightful discoveries.
- More than just a meal, diving into Toronto’s deep-dish pizza scene is an immersive culinary journey, promising a blend of authenticity, innovation, and sheer indulgence.
FAQs
- How is Detroit-style pizza different?
Detroit-style pizza features a thick, crispy crust, often likened to a “deep-dish focaccia”, and is square-shaped.
- Which drinks pair best with deep-dish pizzas?
Craft beers, red wines like Cabernet Sauvignon, classic colas, and iced tea are popular choices.
- Are there vegetarian deep-dish options available?
Absolutely! Many pizzerias offer vegetarian toppings and combinations for deep-dish pizzas.
- Is there a gluten-free deep-dish pizza in Toronto?
Some pizzerias, like Pizza Libretto, offer gluten-free crust options, but it’s always good to check beforehand. Those seeking a gluten-free option will be delighted to discover the best spots for gluten-free pizza in Toronto, combining great taste with dietary inclusivity.
- How filling is a slice of deep-dish pizza compared to regular pizza?
Given its thick crust and generous toppings, a slice of deep-dish is typically more filling than a regular slice.
- What are popular side dishes to accompany deep-dish pizzas?
Caesar salads, garlic bread, antipasti, and roasted vegetables are commonly paired with deep-dish pizzas.
- Can I get deep-dish pizza delivered in Toronto?
Yes, many pizzerias offer delivery services, and some, like General Assembly Pizza, even have pizza subscription services.
- Are there vegan deep-dish pizzas available in Toronto?
Some places, like Blondies Pizza, offer vegan pizza options, ensuring dietary inclusivity. Consider a lighter yet equally tantalizing option by visiting the Toronto’s top vegan pizza shops, renowned for their innovative and flavorful plant-based pies.